The Senate Agriculture Committee spent much of Tuesday’s confirmation hearing for President Donald Trump’s two nominees to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) on the agency’s fight with states over prediction markets, a fight in which tribes have also raised concerns.

Neither Matthew Rowland, the Democratic nominee, nor Nathan Anonick, the Republican nominee, took a strong stand against the agency’s approach to event contracts (yes-or-no contracts on whether a future event happens), which it says belong under federal derivatives law. But Rowland told senators at the hearing that the commission should “think long and hard about balancing the public interest against the kind of economic usefulness of these contracts.” He also cited Regulation 40.11, a 2011 CFTC rule that bars registered exchanges from listing event contracts tied to gaming, terrorism, war or assassination.

Rowland told the committee it was hard to comment on the agency’s pending lawsuits, but added, “I’m certainly very sympathetic to the concerns that the states and tribes have raised.”

Anonick said the legal uncertainty makes the question a complicated one and that he would follow any Supreme Court ruling that settles it. “It’s a very charged, emotional issue, and I appreciate how sensitive it is,” he said.


Get Unchained’s crypto news in your inbox with the free Unchained Daily newsletter.


Smith Calls It ‘a Legal Issue’

Sen. Tina Smith, D-Minn., objected to Anonick’s view. “I don’t think that this is an emotional issue. I think this is a legal issue,” she said, calling it “a core legal tenet that is laid out in the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act,” along with states’ right to regulate sports betting. Smith also told the nominees the law is clear that “jurisdiction over sports gambling rests in the hands of states and also with tribes” and said she believed prediction markets were operating in violation of those laws.

Kalshi, Polymarket and Coinbase are among the CFTC-regulated platforms that states have taken to court, and federal judges have split on whether state gambling laws apply. Under Chair Mike Selig, the agency’s lone sitting commissioner, the CFTC has claimed exclusive authority over event contracts and has proposed rules for the sector, which Rowland said he hoped to work on.

Staffing, Seats and Trump Family Ties

One senator noted that the agency’s workforce has shrunk by about a quarter under Selig and the administration’s federal workforce cuts, and both nominees said they were open to hiring as needed. Both also backed filling all five commission seats, with Anonick saying “a full commission is the best approach to sound, durable policy.”

Sen. Raphael Warnock, D-Ga., citing press reports about the CFTC and firms with business ties to the Trump family, asked, “Should a company’s ties with the president or his family ever affect how the CFTC treats it?” Rowland said “the law needs to be enforced fairly without fear or favor, and so the answer is no.” Anonick agreed that “the law should apply equally and fairly to everyone. It should not matter who is involved.”

Unchained’s Read

If both nominees are confirmed, the CFTC’s prediction-market agenda would no longer sit with a single commissioner, and one of the two new votes would belong to a nominee who wants the public-interest test applied with care. That could move part of the fight from the courtroom to the commission itself, through Regulation 40.11’s review of which event contracts exchanges may list.

The committee still has to vote before the nominations go to the full Senate. A new Congress begins in January, and nominations not acted on by then would generally have to be resubmitted.

Related Listen: CME vs. Kalshi. Is Washington Picking a Winner in Prediction Markets?