Sen. Adam Schiff of California and eight other Democratic senators asked the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to withdraw a Nov. 5 order that tells prediction markets to stop restricting traders by location, arguing in a letter dated Nov. 16 that it collides with court orders in several states.
“Your unilateral decision directly conflicts with active court orders, undermines state and tribal law, and must be reversed,” the senators wrote to CFTC Chairman Michael Selig.
The order is an interpretation of the CFTC’s impartial access rule, which requires designated contract markets (DCMs), the federally registered exchanges where event contracts trade, to offer fair and open access to their markets. The agency said in its release that DCMs “must cease domestic geographic restrictions that violate the Impartial Access Requirements within 30 days,” or explain to the agency’s Division of Market Oversight why they can’t. Selig said derivatives markets “must operate on a uniform basis at a national scale.”
Geofencing, or blocking users based on where they are, has been how platforms complied with state orders. “What has happened for the most part is these prediction markets have just moved to geo-block the state,” Katherine Kirkpatrick Bos said on Unchained’s DEX in the City in July, describing how operators responded to Michigan and other states seeking to halt sports contracts.
Get Unchained’s crypto news in your inbox with the free Unchained Daily newsletter.
Court Orders and Tribal Lands
The letter cites decisions from the federal appeals courts for the Sixth and Ninth Circuits holding that state gambling law still reaches prediction markets. In the senators’ telling, those geofences exist because judges demanded them: courts in Michigan, Nevada and Washington, and in cases involving two California tribes, told platforms to pull certain contracts. “The Commission now appears to be encouraging prediction markets to offer prohibited contracts in contempt of these court orders during active litigation,” they added.
They also said the CFTC acted “just hours after” a federal court in Northern California ordered Kalshi to geofence around tribal lands in Blue Lake Rancheria v. Kalshi, which they said “raises concerns that the Commission may be coordinating with platforms currently engaged in litigation” and nudging them to break state and tribal gaming laws.
What the Senators Want
Their main ask is that the CFTC pull the interpretation, or at least put it on hold while the lawsuits play out. Failing that, they want the agency to confirm that three kinds of location blocks are allowed: those a judge orders, those put in place to comply with the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act or a tribal-state compact, and those an exchange chooses on its own. They also asked the CFTC to preserve records back to Jan. 1, 2025, and to reply by Nov. 23.
Signers include Amy Klobuchar, ranking member of the Senate Agriculture Committee, along with Catherine Cortez Masto, Jacky Rosen, Maria Cantwell, Alex Padilla, Elissa Slotkin, Patty Murray and Gary Peters.
The letter lands as the CFTC presses its case against state enforcement. The agency and the Justice Department sued Arkansas after the state’s attorney general sued Kalshi, and the CFTC and the Justice Department sued Louisiana on Nov. 13, the agency said. In a separate X post on Nov. 16 that did not mention the letter, Selig wrote that he “will not allow states to file lawsuits against our exchanges unchecked.”
Related Listen: CME vs. Kalshi. Is Washington Picking a Winner in Prediction Markets?
